Updated on 2024/09/28

写真a

 
OTANI Masashi
 
Organization
Language Education Center Foreign Language Education Division Lecturer
Title
Lecturer
Contact information
メールアドレス
Profile
Dedicated and knowledgeable educator with more than 10 years of teaching & advising experience in Japan and USA with Ph.D. in Curriculum & Instruction, Master's degree in TESOL, and B.A. in Economics.
External link

Degree 3

  1. Doctor of Philosophy in Curriculum and Instruction ( 2022.8   University of Florida ) 

  2. Master of Arts in Education ( 2013.3   Soka University ) 

  3. Bachelor of Arts in Economics ( 2011.3   Soka University ) 

Research Interests 5

  1. Heritage language

  2. Investment

  3. Language education

  4. Multilingualism

  5. Bilingualism

Research Areas 6

  1. Humanities & Social Sciences / Foreign language education

  2. Humanities & Social Sciences / Educational technology

  3. Humanities & Social Sciences / Linguistics

  4. Humanities & Social Sciences / Japanese language education

  5. Humanities & Social Sciences / Education

  6. Humanities & Social Sciences / Area studies

▼display all

Current Research Project and SDGs 1

  1. Language education

Research History 5

  1. Nagoya University   Language Education Center (Foreign Language Education Division)   Lecturer

    2023.4

      More details

    Country:Japan

  2. Universitetet i Tromsø, UiT   Department of Language and Culture   Researcher

    2022.8 - 2023.1

      More details

    Country:Norway

  3. Jacksonville Japanese School   Elementary School & Middle School

    2018.9 - 2022.5

      More details

    Country:United States

  4. University of Florida   College of Education, UEP/UEC Program   Instructor

    2017.8 - 2021.12

      More details

    Country:United States

  5. Soka University   World Language Center   Assistant Professor

    2013.4 - 2016.3

      More details

    Country:Japan

Education 4

  1. University of Florida   College of Education   School of Teaching and Learning (ESOL/Bilingual Education)

    2016.8 - 2022.8

      More details

    Country: United States

  2. Soka University   Graduate School of Letters   International Language Education (TESOL)

    2011.4 - 2013.3

      More details

    Notes: English Medium Instruction

  3. University of Miami

    2009.5 - 2009.12

      More details

    Country: United States

    Notes: Exchange Program

  4. Soka University   Faculty of Economics   Department of Economics

    2006.4 - 2011.3

      More details

    Notes: Studied economics in English.

Committee Memberships 3

  1. Language Education Center, Nagoya University   Editorial Board, Nagoya University Journal of Language and Education  

    2023.4   

      More details

    Committee type:Academic society

  2. University of Florida   Executive Board, Student Alliance in Graduates in Education (SAGE)  

    2017.5 - 2018.4   

      More details

    Committee type:Other

    As an executive board member of the graduate student body, I was involved in our department's projects such as workshops, symposiums, and professional networking.

  3. Soka University   Instructional Design Committee  

    2014.4 - 2016.3   

      More details

    Committee type:Other

    As an assistant professor, I was involved in in-house instructional design projects.

Awards 4

  1. Certificates of Outstanding Merit, University of Florida International Center

    2021.11   University of Florida  

     More details

    Country:United States

  2. 海外学会参加旅費援助

    2019.3   アメリカ研究振興会  

    大谷将史

     More details

    Award type:Award from Japanese society, conference, symposium, etc.  Country:Japan

    カナダで開催のAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA)年次国際会議にて発表

  3. Homes Scholar

    2018.9   American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education  

    Masashi Otani

     More details

    Award type:Award from international society, conference, symposium, etc.  Country:United States

    Being a Holmes Scholar was an opportunity to regularly receive feedback from multilingual and multicultural faculty members and fellow scholars.

  4. Travel Award

    2017.5   Sunshine State TESOL   Preparing mainstream elementary teacher educators to work with ELLs: Observations from Florida

    Masashi Otani

     More details

    Award type:Award from international society, conference, symposium, etc.  Country:United States

 

Papers 8

  1. A cultural anthropologist’s perspective on heritage language and education: In conversation with Neriko Musha Doerr Reviewed International coauthorship International journal

    Neriko Musha Doerr, Masashi Otani

    Journal of Education for Multilingualism   Vol. 1 ( 1 ) page: 133 - 144   2024.8

     More details

    Authorship:Corresponding author   Language:English   Publishing type:Research paper (scientific journal)  

  2. A Japanese American middle schooler’s investment in Japanese language learning Reviewed

    Masashi Otani

    Nagoya University Journal of Language and Education   Vol. 1 ( 1 ) page: 1 - 26   2024.3

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:English   Publishing type:Research paper (bulletin of university, research institution)   Publisher:Language Education Center, Nagoya University  

    DOI: 10.18999/nagdgk.1.1

  3. Five Japanese American students and their investment in a Japanese Hoshuko in the United States International journal

    Masashi Otani

    ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Global     2022.8

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:English   Publishing type:Doctoral thesis   Publisher:University of Florida  

    The study investigates what the Saturday Japanese schools (Hoshuko) mean to Japanese American students. In the United States, Hoshuko prepare Japanese students to return to Japan. While previous studies have revealed the experiences of Hoshuko students, little is known about how Japanese American students who plan to stay in the U.S. perceive their education experiences at Hoshuko. As Hoshuko teachers implement the Japanese Ministry of Education’s (MEXT) curriculum, their goal is to teach the subjects as they are taught in Japan. By learning these subjects, Hoshuko students are able to return to Japan without worrying about catching up to their peers. However, the number of students born in the United States and not planning to move to Japan is increasing. For instance, in the U.S. Southern states, half of Hoshuko students plan to live in the United States permanently (North America South District Hoshu Jugyo Ko, 2019). This trend would require Japanese curriculum developers to reconsider the relationship between Hoshuko students and the MEXT curriculum. Therefore, the study asks the Japanese American students who intend to stay in the United States to describe: 1) what they value about their participation in their Hoshuko, and 2) their perspectives on the linguistic and academic goals of the Hoshuko.

    Using Darvin and Norton’s (2015) model of investment, the study captures how each Hoshuko student invested in their Hoshuko. In this framework, student’s investment is documented in relation to three interconnected aspects: ideology, capital, and identity. The study used a multiple case study approach, and data was collected through individual and group interviews, photo stories, classroom observations, student surveys, and textbooks and assignments. Five Japanese American Hoshuko students were selected through convenience sampling. Data analysis was conducted using the themes that were generated from the participants’ interview responses. Thus, the study includes three major findings. First, friendship is the primary reason for the participants to continue to invest in their Hoshuko. Second, while the Hoshuko is designed as a Japanese monolingual space, multilingualism is a norm among the participants. Third, the Hoshuko is a community where the participants are able to interact with Japanese community members.

  4. 英語教育の未知なる可能性:日本におけるリベラル教育, ペダゴジー・オブ・ケアリング, アクティブ・ラーニングの位置づけ Reviewed International coauthorship

    大谷将史, ウイサル・フセイン, リー・ヨンジク

    言語教師教育   Vol. 6 ( 1 ) page: 144 - 151   2019.3

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:Japanese   Publishing type:Research paper (conference, symposium, etc.)  

  5. リメディアル英語教育におけるICT活用事例(自律的英語学習の促進に向けて) Invited Reviewed

    佐野真歩, 大谷将史

    日本リメディアル教育学会第11回全国大会予稿集     page: 136 - 137   2015.8

     More details

    Authorship:Corresponding author   Language:Japanese   Publishing type:Research paper (conference, symposium, etc.)  

  6. Japanese EFL learners' expressions of thanks and disagreement Reviewed

    Masashi Otani, Yuuki Ogawa

    The 2014 JALT PanSIG Proceedings     page: 155 - 164   2015.5

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:English   Publishing type:Research paper (conference, symposium, etc.)  

  7. 電子ポートフォリオを活用した言語学習イベントと参加者のやる気を促す仕掛け Invited Reviewed

    大谷将史

    大学eラーニング協議会・8大学連携合同FD/SDフォーラム予稿集     2015.2

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:Japanese   Publishing type:Research paper (conference, symposium, etc.)  

    Other Link: https://eight-univ.spub.chitose.ac.jp/

  8. Communicative language teaching in English at Japanese junior high schools Reviewed

    Masashi Otani

    The Bulletin of the Graduate School, Soka University   Vol. 35   page: 285 - 305   2013.12

     More details

    Authorship:Lead author   Language:English   Publishing type:Research paper (bulletin of university, research institution)  

▼display all

Books 1

  1. 頻出順英単語2000+:例文で自然に身に付く!:webアプリ付き

    岡崎弘信(編著)(デジタル版練習問題作成)

    国際語学社  2014.10  ( ISBN:978-4877317126

     More details

    Book type:Textbook, survey, introduction

Presentations 17

  1. Linguistic perspectives of Japanese as a heritage language (JHL) adolescents in the southern United States

    Masashi Otani

    The 27th Research Roundtable for Bilingualism as a First Language - Bilingual Education in Japan  2023.10.1  The Research Association of Bilingualism as a First Language

     More details

    Event date: 2023.10

    Language:Japanese   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Online  

  2. Lessons from being involved in bilingual education in a US southern state Invited

    Masashi Otani

    2023.9.23 

     More details

    Event date: 2023.9

    Language:Japanese   Presentation type:Oral presentation (invited, special)  

    Venue:Online   Country:Japan  

  3. Textbook and classroom activities at Japanese Hoshuko in America International conference

    Masashi Otani

    National Heritage Language Resource Center (NHLRC) Fourth International Conference on Heritage/Community Languages  University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) National Heritage Language Resource Center (NHLRC)

     More details

    Event date: 2022.6

    Language:English   Presentation type:Poster presentation  

    Venue:Los Angeles, California   Country:United States  

  4. Bilingual mainstream teachers and the impact of prior linguistic and cultural experiences on teaching English language learners International conference

    Ahyea Jo, Ester de Jong, Masashi Otani, Yong-Jik Lee

    American Educational Research Association (AERA) 2019 Annual Meeting  American Educational Research Association (AERA)

     More details

    Event date: 2019.4

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Toronto, Canada   Country:Canada  

  5. Inclusion and equity for emergent bilinguals in a rural district International conference

    Ester de Jong, Huseyin Uysal, Masashi Otani

    The 4th Annual College of Education (COE) Research Symposium 2019  College of Education, University of Florida

     More details

    Event date: 2019.3

    Language:English   Presentation type:Poster presentation  

    Venue:Gainesville, Florida   Country:United States  

  6. A language educator’s journey: What did Soka education do to me? International conference

    Masashi Otani

    The 1st International Conference on Ikeda/Soka Studies in Education  DePaul University

     More details

    Event date: 2018.8

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Chicago, Illinois   Country:United States  

  7. Sustaining ELL expertise: Teacher educators and ELL infusion International conference

    Ester de Jong, Masashi Otani, Shuzhang Li, Hyunjin Jinna Kim, Aicha Ouzia, Cindy Naranjo, Feifei Fan

    TESOL 2018 International Convention & English Language Expo  TESOL International Association

     More details

    Event date: 2018.3

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Chicago, Illinois   Country:United States  

  8. Preparing mainstream elementary teacher educators to work with ELLs: Observations from Florida International conference

    Ester de Jong, Feifei Fan, Masashi Otani, Hyunjin Jinna Kim

    Sunshine State TESOL 39th Annual Statewide Conference  Sunshine State TESOL (Florida Association of Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages)

     More details

    Event date: 2017.5

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Palm Beach, Florida   Country:United States  

  9. e-Learningによる英語力強化教育システムの構築(オリジナルのテストと教材の効果的な組み合わせによる主体的学びの促進) Invited

    早瀬博範, 江口誠, 林裕子, 滝口晴生, 金井彩香, 片岡徹, ジェームズ・E・アリソン, 山本成代, 大谷将史, 佐野真歩, 石原知英, 藤岡克則, 田中寿郎, 藤平明彦アンドリュー

    大学eラーニング協議会フォーラム2015  大学eラーニング協議会

     More details

    Event date: 2016.3

    Language:Japanese   Presentation type:Poster presentation  

    Venue:長野県   Country:Japan  

  10. Application of e-portfolios in maximizing low level Japanese EFL students’ study time International conference

    Masashi Otani

    The JACET 54th International Convention  The Japan Association of College English Teachers (JACET)

     More details

    Event date: 2015.8

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Kagoshima   Country:Japan  

  11. リメディアル英語教育におけるICT活用事例(自立的英語学習の促進に向けて) Invited

    佐野真歩, 大谷将史

    日本リメディアル教育学会第11回全国大会  日本リメディアル教育学会

     More details

    Event date: 2015.8

    Language:Japanese   Presentation type:Oral presentation (invited, special)  

    Venue:北海道   Country:Japan  

  12. EFL freshman university students’ learning beliefs

    Masashi Otani, Yuuki Ogawa

    The 14th Annual JALT PanSIG National Conference  The Japan Association of Language Teaching (JALT)

     More details

    Event date: 2015.5

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Hyogo   Country:Japan  

  13. 電子学習ポートフォリオを活用した言語学習支援イベントと参加者のやる気を促す仕掛け Invited

    大谷将史

    大学eラーニング協議会・8大学連携合同FD/SDフォーラム  大学eラーニング協議会, 千歳科学技術大学, 北星学園大学, 桜の聖母短期大学, 創価大学, 山梨大学, 愛知大学, 愛媛大 学, 佐賀大学

     More details

    Event date: 2015.2

    Language:Japanese   Presentation type:Oral presentation (invited, special)  

    Venue:東京都   Country:Japan  

    Other Link: https://eight-univ.spub.chitose.ac.jp/

  14. Incorporating a dictogloss activity into an elementary level college English class Invited

    Masashi Otani

    Japan Association for Media English Studies-English Education/Media Studies SIG 9th Regional Conference  Japan Association for Media English Studies-English Education/Media Studies SIG

     More details

    Event date: 2015.1

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (invited, special)  

    Venue:Tokyo   Country:Japan  

  15. Japanese junior high school EFL teachers’ transitions of teaching and learning practices International conference

    Masashi Otani

    The 12th International Asia TEFL Conference  AsiaTEFL (Asian Association of Teaching English as a Foreign Language)

     More details

    Event date: 2014.8

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Kuching   Country:Malaysia  

  16. Japanese EFL learners' expressions of thanks and disagreement

    Masashi Otani, Yuuki Ogawa

    The 13th Annual JALT PanSIG Conference   The Japan Association of Language Teaching (JALT)

     More details

    Event date: 2014.5

    Language:English   Presentation type:Poster presentation  

    Venue:Miyazaki   Country:Japan  

  17. Communicative language teaching in English at Japanese junior high schools International conference

    Masashi Otani

    The 9th CamTESOL Annual International Conference  CamTESOL (Cambodian Association of Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages)

     More details

    Event date: 2013.2

    Language:English   Presentation type:Oral presentation (general)  

    Venue:Phnom Penh   Country:Cambodia  

▼display all

Research Project for Joint Research, Competitive Funding, etc. 1

  1. 学士力養成のための共通基盤システムを活用した主体的学びの促進 英語ワーキンググループ

    2013.4 - 2016.3

    大学間連携共同教育推進事業 

      More details

    Authorship:Other  Grant type:Competitive

    千歳科学技術大学(代表校)、北星学園大学、桜の聖母短期大学、創価大学、山梨大学、愛知大学、愛媛大学、佐賀大学の連携8大学が5年間の事業を通じて、(1)文理共通で必要となる初年次キャリアを意識した数学・英語・日本語・情報及び学習態度(学習者特性)を測定するテスト(プレ及びポスト)を作成し、さらに(2)プレテストの後に自学自習で知識定着を図れるeラーニング教材及びモデルシラバスを作成し、共通基盤クラウド上で運用できるようにした。

    自らの役割:英語ワーキンググループメンバーとしてメンバー校のある都道府県に出張し、教材開発のための会議に参加した。当時の所属で会った創価大学では、事業に関係するテストの実施や開発した教材のパイロット的な活用を行った。

    関連研究成果: e-Learning による 英語力強化教育システムの構築(オリジナルのテストと教材の効果的な組み合わせによる主体的学びの促進)

    早瀬博範, 江口誠, 林裕子, 滝口晴生, 金井彩香, 片岡徹, ジェームズ・E・アリソン, 山本成代, 大谷将史, 佐野真歩, 石原知英, 藤岡克則, 田中寿郎, 藤平明彦アンドリュー

    大学eラーニング協議会フォーラム2015 大学eラーニング協議会

 

Teaching Experience (On-campus) 11

  1. Academic English Basic

    2024

  2. Academic English Advanced

    2024

  3. Special English Seminar A

    2024

  4. Academic English Seminar

    2024

  5. Academic English Communication

    2024

  6. Academic English Intermediate

    2024

  7. Academic English Basic

    2023

  8. Academic English Advanced

    2023

  9. Academic English Communication

    2023

  10. Academic English Intermediate

    2023

  11. Advanced Reading 2

    2023

▼display all

Teaching Experience (Off-campus) 12

  1. TSL5142 ESOL Curriculum, Methods, and Assessment for Early Childhood Education

    2019.1 - 2020.5 College of Education, University of Florida (Graduate School))

     More details

    Level:Postgraduate  Country:United States

  2. TSL4100 ESOL Curriculum, Methods, and Assessment

    2017.8 - 2021.12 College of Education, University of Florida)

     More details

    Level:Undergraduate (specialized)  Country:United States

  3. eLearning Program Coordinator (World Language Center)

    2014.4 - 2015.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Other  Country:Japan

  4. TOEFL iBT/IELTS Speaking Center Advisor (World Language Center)

    2013.4 - 2016.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Other  Country:Japan

  5. English Study Consultation Advisor (World Language Center)

    2013.4 - 2016.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Other  Country:Japan

  6. EDF 6812: International and Comparative Education

    2018.1 - 2018.5 College of Education, University of Florida (Graduate School))

     More details

    Level:Postgraduate  Country:United States

    In our interconnected and interdependent global world, academics, educational policy makers, non-profit leaders, non-governmental organizational (NGO) leaders, and government officials must actively acknowledge and address the global forces shaping educational policies and practices today. This requires an interdisciplinary approach that reflects a deep understanding of the historical, political, social, and economic dimensions of education within a given nation (intra-state), as well as among various nations.

    Using an equity/equality framework, this course builds a broad knowledge-base in order to frame education in the current global context. The course examines regional educational issues to deepen students’ knowledge and to situate global educational equity issues such as development, gender, language, and race. Students will read educational texts, theoretical articles, and empirical research studies; they will also access digital resources
    (videos, audio, websites) and engage in small-group book clubs to support their learning. By the end of this course, students will be prepared to situate their own school or educational system within a global context, and have a solid understanding of comparative education methods.

    Throughout the course of the semester we will examine some or all of the following: Comparative Studies, Education Abroad/International Education, Development Education,
    Globalization, and Theory and Research in Comparative Education. These topics will be examined of in light of the theoretical, methodological, and conceptual aspects of the field.

  7. Mentoring for First Year Ph.D. Students

    2020.1 - 2020.5 College of Education, University of Florida (Graduate School))

     More details

    Level:Graduate (liberal arts)  Country:United States

  8. Japanese Language Arts for Elementary & Middle Schoolers

    2018.9 - 2022.5 Jacksonville Japanese School (Florida, USA))

     More details

    Level:Other  Country:United States

  9. English A

    2013.4 - 2014.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Undergraduate (liberal arts) 

  10. English B

    2013.4 - 2014.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Undergraduate (liberal arts) 

  11. English I & II

    2014.4 - 2016.3 Soka University)

     More details

    Level:Undergraduate (liberal arts) 

  12. English III & IV

    2014.4 - 2016.3 Soka University)

▼display all

 

Social Contribution 5

  1. Community Development Expert at Homigaoka International Center (NPO)

    Role(s):Lecturer, Advisor, Informant, Planner, Organizing member, Demonstrator

    Homigaoka International Center (NPO), Toyota-shi, Aichi Prefecture  2023.8

     More details

    Type:Visiting lecture

    "We conduct projects that aim to promote mutual understanding and welfare improvement among multinational residents through community-based international exchange and multicultural coexistence in a wide range of local communities" (Homigaoka International Center, 2002-2023).

  2. サウジアラビアの中堅英語教員を対象としたマイクロティーチング研修の開発と実施

    Role(s):Lecturer

    サウジアラビア教育省(要請元機関)  フロリダ大学教育大学院  2019.12

     More details

    Audience: Teachers

    Type:Seminar, workshop

    サウジアラビア教育省とフロリダ大学教育大学院の教育交流プログラムの一環として、複数あった研修のうちの一つを担当した。対象はサウジアラビアの学校で英語教員を10年から15年務めている方々であった。

  3. トップアスリート学生の学術メンタリング

    Role(s):Lecturer, Advisor

    全米大学体育協会(NCAA)  フロリダ大学体育協会(UAA)  2017.8 - 2022.4

     More details

    Audience: College students

    Type:Visiting lecture

    各国の代表やオリンピック・世界大会出場レベルのアスリート学生らに学術面のメンタリング機会を提供した。全米屈指のスポーツ強豪校であるフロリダ大学においてバイリンガル教育を専門としていたことを評価されてのスカウト採用であった。また日本においても後にプロ野球ドラフト1位クラスの選手となった学生らを学術指導した経験が評価された。

  4. Humanities and Social Sciences in Brazil, Australia & China

    Role(s):Presenter, Planner, Organizing member, Report writing

    Japanese Graduate Student Association in the United States (JGSAU)  2020 Winter - International Graduate School Orientation  Online (From Florida, USA)  2020.12

     More details

    Audience: College students, Graduate students, General

    Type:Lecture

    This orientation is particularly for those who have some plans to study in graduate schools of humanities and social sciences abroad.

  5. Newsletter Editor

    Role(s):Chief editor, Editer, Contribution

    Japanese Graduate Student Association in the United States (JGSAU)  2020 - 2021

     More details

    Audience: College students, Graduate students, General

    Type:Promotional material

Academic Activities 4

  1. 英語学習者を補助的に支援する主任教育者のための研修開発 International contribution

    Role(s):Planning/Implementing academic research

    フロリダ州スワニー郡 教育委員会 (要請元機関)  2017.10 - 2018.6

     More details

    Type:Academic research 

    フロリダ州のスワニー郡からの要請により、郡内学区の教員研修開発を行った。具体的には、近年増加しているスワニー郡内のスペイン語圏からの移民の子どもたちを教える学校教員向けの研修開発であった。英語学習段階の生徒たちを教えるためには第二言語教授法の知識とスキルが必要なため、第二言語教授法について自分のペースで学べるオンラインコースの開発と現場での対面の研修開発を行った。状況を把握するために、スワニー郡内すべての小学校から高校までを訪問し、全ての学年の英語学習者とその担当教員らに個人インタビューとフォーカスグループインタビューを実施した。そこから得られたデータと第二言語教授法の先行研究を踏まえて、オンライン研修教材と対面研修を開発した。

    他メンバー: フロリダ大学教職研究科 研究科長(2022年8月まで) ディヨン・エスター教授、ノックスカレッジ(イリノイ州) ウイサル・フセイン客員助教

  2. Reviewer for an international journal in linguistics (Scopus-indexed) International contribution

    Role(s):Peer review

    2019

     More details

    Type:Peer review 

  3. Organizing Committee, 3rd Annual COE Research Symposium International contribution

    Role(s):Planning, management, etc., Panel moderator, session chair, etc.

    College of Education, University of Florida  ( College of Education, University of Florida ) 2018.4

     More details

    Type:Competition, symposium, etc. 

  4. Organizing Committee, 2nd Annual COE Research Symposium International contribution

    Role(s):Planning, management, etc., Panel moderator, session chair, etc.

    College of Education, University of Florida  ( College of Education, University of Florida ) 2017.3

     More details

    Type:Competition, symposium, etc.